Kristin Chenoweth and Jennifer Lopez play neighbors in the new thriller The Boy Next Door and we honestly can’t decide which one we envy more. The Tony winner stopped by Late Night to chat with Seth Meyers about the first time she met J-Lo and what it’s like to be on vocal rest in preparation for a Broadway return in On the Twentieth Century. “About once a night, you gotta shut it down. After I get home at six, I don’t speak.” The upside, as Cheno shows us, is that she’s gotten really great at charades. She also discusses the ridiculous birthday gift she recently got her dad. Take a look at the clips below to see why!